1.1 How Science Works

Flowchart of the scientific inquiry process, with yes and no feedback loops.
A linear flowchart showing the steps of the scientific method for investigation. (Credit: Wikimedia Commons)

Before diving into learning more about Planet Earth, we begin with a review of the process of science. Many prior textbooks and publications will describe the scientific method as a linear procedure for investigation, as depicted in this flowchart with blue boxes and straight lines. Although science is typically summarized after the completion of the research as a series of steps that build upon one another (starting with a question, moving to gathering data, formulating and testing a hypothesis, etc.), the actual process for how scientific discoveries and advancement are made is much more complex.

We now acknowledge that a linear visualization is oversimplified and not an accurate representation of how science is actually carried out. The flowchart below represents the process of scientific inquiry as much more dynamic, building new knowledge of and benefits for the natural world not just by individual scientists but through community contributions. Take a moment to review and reflect upon this circular portrayal  of science as a non-linear, dynamic, and iterative process.

 

Long Description

A flowchart showing five steps for the scientific method: Identify the Problem (question), then Gather Data (research), then Hypothesis, then Test Hypothesis (experiment), then Does the New Data Agree? The choices are either Yes or No. If Yes, then back to Test Hypothesis (experiment) and Does the New Data Agree? and either the Yes or No choice. If No, then Hypothesis, Test Hypothesis (experiment), Does the New Data Agree? and either the Yes or No choice.

 

Circular flowchart of the process of science. See link to text description of this flowchart in the caption.
A flowchart demonstrating the process of science. In contrast to the linear steps of the simplified scientific method, the process of science is non-linear. (Credit: © University of California Museum of Paleontology, Understanding Science. Text description of flowchart. This image used with CC BY-NC-SA 4.0)
Long Description

A circular flowchart shows an iterative process connecting exploration and discovery, testing ideas, benefits and outcomes, and community analysis and feedback. Thick gray curved arrows link the three main colored circles, indicating movement between stages.

At the top, a pink circle titled “Exploration and Discovery” contains five activities: making observations, asking questions, sharing data and ideas, finding inspiration, and exploring the literature. Arrows from outside point toward this circle. The left-side prompts are new technology, practical problem, and curiosity; the right-side prompts are personal motivation, serendipity, and surprising observation.

The large green circle in the center is divided into two sections: “Gathering data” and “Interpreting data.” Gathering data compares hypotheses with expected and actual results or observations. Interpreting data leads to possible support for a hypothesis, opposition to a hypothesis, revised or new hypotheses, or revised assumptions. The phrase “Supportive, contradictory, surprising or inconclusive data may…” introduces these outcomes.

At lower left, a blue circle titled “Benefits and Outcomes” lists developing technology, addressing societal issues, building knowledge, informing policy, satisfying curiosity, and solving everyday problems. At lower right, a purple circle titled “Community Analysis and Feedback” lists feedback and peer review, replication, discussion with colleagues, publication, coming up with new questions or ideas, and theory building.

Transcribed Text:

EXPLORATION AND DISCOVERY

New technology
Practical problem
Curiosity
Personal motivation
Serendipity
Surprising observation

Making observations
Asking questions
Sharing data and ideas
Finding inspiration
Exploring the literature

Gathering data
Hypotheses
Expected results/observations
Actual results/observations

Interpreting data
Supportive, contradictory, surprising or inconclusive data may…
…support a hypothesis.
…oppose a hypothesis.
…inspire revised/new hypotheses.
…inspire revised assumptions.

TESTING IDEAS

Develop technology
Address societal issues
Build knowledge
Inform policy
Satisfy curiosity
Solve everyday problems

BENEFITS AND OUTCOMES

Feedback and peer review
Replication
Discussion with Colleagues
Publication
Coming up with new questions/ideas
Theory building

Community analysis and feedback

 

To view an example of the process of science during a scientific ocean drilling expedition, check out this video from IODP Expedition 342. For two months in 2012, the drill ship JOIDES Resolution collected sequences of sediment and clay in the northwest Atlantic Ocean. With access to deep-sea material and through immediate laboratory testing and analyses on board, scientists find the linear process of the scientific method does not work. Instead, science at sea is filled with changing directions, collaborating  with those on board and onshore, and adjusting the original research questions.

 

 

Exercise: The Process of Science on Expedition 342

After viewing the video above, please formulate responses to these questions:

  1. What was the purpose of Expedition 342? What research question was the expedition trying to address?
  2. How were the scientists able to learn about climate history? What materials did they study, and from what were the climate data obtained?
  3. As the scientists were carrying out their work, what surprises did they face? What changes did they need to make?
  4. Why is this research important?
  5. Redraw the scientific flowchart from above, inserting information from the video into the appropriate circles.

 

License

Icon for the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License

Scientific Ocean Drilling: Exploration and Discovery through Time Copyright © 2025 by Laura Guertin; Elizabeth Doyle; and Tessa Peixoto is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License, except where otherwise noted.