Chapter 3: Basic Emotion Theory and Social Constructivist Theory
Physiological changes can include changes in the sympathetic nervous system (SNS) and/or parasympathetic nervous system (PNS). In this component, we will also include changes in the brain, such as frontal lobe activation and brain structure activity.
Basic emotions researchers would hypothesize that for the same emotion, people should experience the same changes in physiology. Because we have so many ways to measure physiological changes, basic emotions researchers look for physiological patterns for each emotion. They expect that for each emotion, we should see a different pattern of physiological changes. The basic emotions view that each emotion should correspond to a different physiological pattern is called the autonomic specificity hypothesis (Ekman, 1992; Levenson, 1992).
Research has utilized the Directed Facial Action Task (for more information, see Ekman (2007)) to identify physiological patterns associated with distinct emotions. In this task, participants contract their facial muscles according to experimenter instructions. Three common methods are used to provide instructions:
- A researcher tells participants to show a certain expression on their face. So, “please smile” or “please frown” or “please put your bottom lip down.”
- A research assistant might arrange the participants facial muscles with their hands
- Participants are instructed to hold a pen with their mouth open (to elicit the emotion joy with by smiling) or with their mouth closed (to elicit the emotion sadness by frowning).
This methodology is based on the facial feedback hypothesis, first proposed by Charles Darwin and then William James! This hypothesis states that the emotions we show on our face cause the emotion we feel. For example, if we are in a neutral state, and then we show a frown on our face, that frown will actually make us feel sadness! So, the Directed Facial Action Task assumes that rearranging facial muscles causes participants to feel the discrete emotion shown on the face.
A classic study (Levenson, Ekman, & Friesen, 1990) used the directed facial action task to test the autonomic specificity hypothesis. In this study, participants displayed six different facial expressions: anger, fear, sadness, disgust, happiness, and surprise. After displaying each facial expression, four physiological measures were taken: heart rate, finger temperature, skin conductance, and muscle activity. According to the autonomic specificity hypothesis, each of the six facial expressions should cause a unique pattern of physiological changes.
The figure below demonstrates the results. The x-axis shows the six facial expressions, and the y-axis represents the change in physiology from baseline. Bars of the same color indicates that those emotions did not show significant differences in the corresponding physiological measures. For instance, for heart rate – anger, fear, and sadness resulted in the same increase in heart rate. Bars with different colors represent significant differences between the emotions. For instance, for heart rate – happiness showed a significantly difference change in heart rate from all other emotions except for sadness (as noted).
Physiological Change from Baseline for Six Discrete Emotions
Physiological Patterns for Each Emotion based on Levenson et al. (1990)
- Anger: ↑HR, ↑Finger Temp, ↑Skin conductance, ↓Muscle Activity
- Fear: ↑HR, ↓Finger Temp, ↑Skin conductance, ↑Muscle Activity
- Sadness: ↑HR, ↑Finger Temp, ↑Skin conductance, ↓Muscle Activity
- Disgust: ↑HR, ↑Finger Temp, ↑Skin conductance, ↑Muscle Activity
- Happiness: ↑HR, ↑Finger Temp, ↑Skin conductance, ↑Muscle Activity
- Surprise: 0 HR, ↑Finger Temp, ↑Skin conductance, ↓Muscle Activity
- The six emotions did not show differences in muscle activity.
- Heart rate and finger temperature demonstrated the most differences between emotions.
- Many of the physiological measures are better at distinguishing among negative emotions than positive emotions.
Finally, keep in mind that Schachter and Singer would state that physiological change only determines our arousal, whereas our cognitive appraisals determine our emotion label.
A later study (Levenson, Ekman, Heider, & Friesen, 1992) looked for universality in physiological patterns by recruiting Minangkabau and American participants. Minangkabau is a local tribe located in the Indonesia province of West Sumatera (called Sumatera Beret by locals). Similar to the prior study, participants were instructed to make facial expressions associated with the following distinct emotions: anger, fear, sadness, disgust, and happiness/joy. While holding the facial expression, seven measures of physiology were taken – we will only discuss heart rate, finger temperature, and skin conductance. Results are displayed below. The top row displays the results for Minangkabau participants, while the bottom row displays results for American participants.
Physiological Change from Baseline for Five Discrete Emotions in US and Minangkabau Participants
- Cross-cultural differences were greatest for skin conductance. Compared to Minangkabau participants, American participants experienced a larger increase in skin conductance from baseline for anger, fear, sadness, and disgust. In fact, the Minangkabau didn’t really show a change in skin conductance for any of the emotions.
- Findings also showed that the differences in heart rate across the emotions approached significance, with the American participants showing greater increases in heart rate.
In conclusion, this study provides evidence of both universality and cross-cultural differences in physiological changes. Why do we see these cross-cultural differences? Well, one explanation might be that Minangkabau truly experience smaller changes in physiology during an emotion episode. A second methodological reason might be that the facial feedback methodology is less effective for Minangkabau participants – maybe this method didn’t elicit the emotions. Or maybe the Minangkabau don’t express emotions as intensely on their faces as Americans do.